304: A Christian Nation? - The Founders, Part 2
What were the personal religious beliefs of Thomas Paine, Patrick Henry, George Mason, James Madison, and Alexander Hamilton, and what role did they see for religion in the United States? Why did Mason and Madison disagree on the "toleration" of religious beliefs? These questions (and others) arise as Blake leads the second part of our discussion of what selected Founding Fathers held as their religious beliefs, what they thought about the role of religion in personal morality and civic society, how they sought to achieve civic tranquility through religious freedom, and how that played in role in forging the disunited colonies into the United States.
0:01 The purpose of separation of church and state is to keep forever from these shores the ceaseless strife that has soaked the soil of Europe with blood for centuries. James Madison Welcome to the United States of Amnesia. We are the podcast that reminds us of what we have forgotten. It is often said that history repeats itself. Mark Twain allegedly said that history doesn't repeat itself, but it rhymes. But over time, many topics have become clouded by biases and oversimplifications, or have become mythologized and now are misunderstood.
0:43 Misunderstanding means learning the wrong lessons from history, perhaps, or even learning nothing at all. And that can leave us poorly prepared for history's next rhyme. In the last episode, we explored the religious views of five of our founding fathers, namely Benjamin Franklin, Thomas Jefferson, George Washington, Samuel Adams, and his cousin John Adams. In this episode, we will explore the religious views of five more of our founding fathers, namely Thomas Paine, Patrick Henry, George Mason, James Madison, and Alexander Hamilton. Let's start with Thomas Paine. Here is the religion of deism, superior to the Christian religion. It is free from all those invented and torturing articles that shock our reason and injure our humanity. Its creed is pure and sublimely simple. It believes in God, and there it rests. It honors reason as the choicest gift of God to man. And this is from Thomas Paine's Age of Enlightenment, which we're going to discuss, his controversial book on religion in the modern age here. So Thomas Paine is the author of Common
2:14 Sense, The Crisis, The Age of Reason, and this last book was strongly opposed to what we saw in our last program by Samuel Adams. And he led probably a more disorderly life than any of the founding fathers. He's dismissed later on by Theodore Roosevelt as a nasty little atheist. But Paine did not regard himself as an atheist. He used his experience as a widely successful pamphleteer and advocate for the cause of the American Revolution to become almost a professional revolutionary. Think of Thomas Paine as kind of like Che Guevara, the Che Guevara of the 18th century, wandering around the world. First, he's in America. Then he makes his way to hang out with radicals over in England. And then he's over in the French Revolution, where he gets into a lot of trouble over there, which we'll get into. This is probably a step up in his mind from his original career, corset maker. Yes, Thomas Paine started out as the maker of ladies' undergarments, or foundation garments. Paine was arrested in 1793 by the French Revolutionary Forces, placed under sentence of death, and only released at the urging of James Monroe, who was American minister in France and later the fourth president. Paine stayed with Monroe and his family for nearly two years until 1795 after his release.
3:45 And this is when he published his critique of Christianity, The Age of Reason. outraged the more orthodox members of the public with its assault on Christianity and organized religion. Specifically, Paine rejected divine revelation and claimed that tales of Christ's miracles, resurrection, and divinity had no more value than pagan myths, asserted that churches oppressed and exploited their members to the benefit only of the clergy, and proclaimed deism to be superior in every way to Christianity, which he regarded as unreconcilable with it. This put the founding fathers, who were all friends with Paine and had admired his stance on American independence during the Revolution, in a difficult position.
4:33 Paine was actually born a Quaker, and he felt his book, even though it's controversial and denounces Christianity, would do a great deal to combat what he saw as a rising tide of outright atheism. Again, we look at certain, you know, when we... dissect these beliefs of pain, they're not at all at odds with the belief structure of the other founding fathers. Miracles he doesn't like. Adams made his comment about, you know, organized religion suppressing free thinking or thought. Pain, though he has a reputation as a radical, these beliefs are kind of in line with the founding fathers, except he expresses them very forcefully. outright denounces christianity but he thought he was fighting against atheism he's fighting against atheism but he kind of gets accused of it yes he gets accused of it that's the irony here he he you know he he creates a lot of problems by basically going a lot further in expressing shared beliefs that that other founding fathers held but held Quietly. Discreetly.
5:49 Yes, very quietly. Again, there is a big difference between talking about deism in a letter to a friend who's like -minded to writing a whole book about it and basically saying Christianity is a bad religion. So this might sound subtle to us, but it's kind of, I think it's a big deal. It's kind of a bridge too far in terms of the ruling orthodoxy of the time. Paine's status as a founding father occurred during the American Revolution, where both the crisis and common sense were popular pamphlets that made the case for independence. Some scholars have argued that Jefferson deliberately adopted the simpler style that Paine kind of patented. in common sense when he wrote the Declaration of Independence.
6:41 And people have compared Jefferson's writings beforehand. They're very convoluted, lots of dependent clauses, the kinds of things that were typical of 18th century educated writing with what the Declaration was, and they see certain parallels there. Common sense did include some deist references, but this Since it's not the central feature of the pamphlet, it did not create any known controversies during the American Revolution. Common Sense has remained in print since its initial publication, and it remains the best -selling work by an American of all time. Something to consider here. F. Scott Fitzgerald famously observed, somewhat pessimistically, that there were no second acts in America. Had he lived longer, he might have changed his mind. Paine's second and even third acts are very different from his career in the Revolution. He became more controversial with time and even a notorious figure amongst Americans. And again, this is mainly due to his denunciation of Christianity in the Age of Reason. His views on the Bible did not unnerve some people. His views on religious groups, all religious groups, as a matter of fact, which were characterized as corrupt organizations, certainly did, leading to breaks with both the Adamses and Washington. In 1787, this is where he met up with the British radicals, and these included William Godwin, father of Mary Shelley,
8:12 the creator of Frankenstein, the poet William Blake. and the scientist Joseph Priestley, all of whom are radical figures on the fringes of British society. In the 1790s, he was named a member of the Assembly, even though he couldn't speak French. Such was his reputation amongst people who were in favor of freedom. He wrote The Age of Reason in response to Edmund Burke's Reflections on the Revolution of France, which was not a positive treatment of the French Revolution or in revolutionary movements in general. It's considered to be the fountainhead of all conservative writings in reaction to the French Revolution.
8:57 As I said, Paine was eventually in over his head as far as the French Revolution was concerned and returned to America after his two -year stay in Monroe's home at the invitation of Thomas Jefferson, who kind of kept Paine at arm's length, but he never really broke with him as we saw with the others. He died in 1809 in, of all places, Greenwich Village in New York City, somehow appropriate. Though influentially politically, it was only during the American Revolution, Paine's extreme views had an impact among a narrow circle of influential people, but impact in terms of establishing religious policy in America would be negligible during the post -revolutionary era. Paine's views do underscore the range of religious views that were held by people who founded the United States, and how at odds they would be with contemporary Christian conservative advocates. Were Paine alive today, he would certainly view their efforts as confirmation of his most severe criticisms of organized religion. Now we're going to talk about Patrick Henry. Patrick Henry actually supported a form of state sponsored religion, putting him at odds with figures like Jefferson and Madison on this issue. Henry believed that Christianity was essential to maintaining public morality
10:30 and social order. He thought that without government support for religion, society would descend into moral chaos. This wasn't about forcing a single denomination on everyone, but rather providing public. financial support for Christian teachers and clergy, broadly. But is this everybody that's going to be supporting, or is it just one religion? Everyone's going to be paying the taxes. Yes, but I mean, in terms of religious persuasions, is everybody's taxes going to one religion or are they going to multiple religions? This would be Church of England. Church of England or Anglicans. Yes. The clearest expression of his views came through his support of the bill establishing a provision for teachers of the Christian religion in Virginia. He argued that the state should levy a tax to support teachers of the Christian religion across denominations. such that citizens could designate which church received their tax money. So sort of like Adams' 1780 Constitution.
11:28 Precisely. He believed Christianity was the foundation for Republican government and civic virtue. He saw government support for religion not as tyranny, but as a practical necessity for a functioning moral republic. Henry is famous for championing liberty. Yet on this issue, he took a position that would have used state power to fund religion, a stance most of the other founders ultimately rejected. But he's only talking about the state in this case, the state of Virginia, not the federal government. You're right. Exactly right. Yes. Which I think is a distinction we need to make here with this, because if we're talking about the United States being founded on Christian principles and the need to maintain a kind of established religion here, then the founding fathers are taking a completely different view, saying this is something that's best left as a state function, not a federal function. Precisely, yes. He believed that true liberty required a moral citizenry. sustained by Christian faith.
12:32 So in his mind, the two positions were entirely consistent. Odd that we have somebody who's Episcopalian coming up to the same conclusions as people who are Congregationalist or Unitarian, which are kind of, they're totally different in their approach to religion. But in this case, the pursuit of morality is something that's kind of causing them to come to similar conclusions. Morality was a driving goal of the founding fathers. Of good citizens. We keep seeing it over and over again. Public morality leads to good behavior publicly. That leads to tranquility in civil society. Tranquility in civil society is a good thing because then you don't wind up with religious wars like they had experienced in the 17th century in Europe and in England in particular. And so on and so forth. I keep seeing this recurring pattern. And you're right. Different faith traditions.
13:26 are coming together towards the same conclusion about religion in civil society, at least. I think this has something to do with Locke, too, because Locke was kind of the great philosopher of the Whigs, which included a lot of dissenters over in England during the 17th century. So diversity is something that is valued. So many faiths are to be tolerated, not any particular one, which is what I think they viewed as problematic over in Britain. And again, we see that pattern coming along too. Again, going back to this idea of civic tranquility. If you start ordering people around and telling them what to believe, they're going to get mad at you and at each other. You won't be tranquil then. Right. So religion is important because it creates a moral framework in which people will behave civilly toward each other, and therefore society will be tranquil.
14:22 But on the other hand, you have to at least tolerate, if that's the right word, all religious belief. Because if you don't tolerate all of them, then the people you're not tolerating are going to rise up against you and you're going to wind up having civil strife, which then you won't have tranquility. So you need both in the way a lot of these guys are thinking. You need religion to give you a moral framework. You need to leave religion alone so that people can believe what they want, have freedom of conscience in order to have a tranquil. way of expressing that you don't want gunpowder appearing mysteriously in the basement of the capitol building by dissenting religious believers marshall's reference to the gunpowder plot 1605 yes in england which we talked about in an earlier episode yeah which was done by catholics who felt themselves oppressed by the state james madison is also famous for another quote along the same lines Religion and government will both exist in greater purity the less they are mixed together. And that's a letter to Edward Livingston in 1822. Next, George Mason. And many of our listeners might say, who is George Mason?
15:37 And that's understandable. He's been largely forgotten. Few of his papers have survived. He could be acerbic and tended to shun political office. He was not a member of the Continental Congress, and so he did not sign the Declaration of Independence. And he mostly is remembered for refusing to sign the Constitution in 1787. And for these two reasons, not having signed either the Declaration of Independence or the Constitution, he's sometimes not considered to be a founding father. But the context here is important. He often is considered the forgotten founder. because, in fact, he did contribute a great deal to the ideas of the Declaration of Independence and of the Bill of Rights. In fact, he did not sign the Constitution because it did not include a Bill of Rights. And he was concerned that a Constitution without a Bill of Rights would make the federal government too powerful. He thought that it would become so powerful that it could lead to a monarchy in the United States or a corrupt aristocracy. that infringed on both individual rights and on the sovereignty of states. I'm just going to say, hmm. Note the sovereignty of states, too. Nowadays, so much of that is conflated with the Confederacy and states' rights and therefore slavery and things like that and secession and those kind of negative things in our past. In fact, though, sovereignty of states is an important part of the way the United States governmental system— The federal system. The federal system works.
17:06 And if you think that doesn't matter, then, you know, do people in California want to do things the way they do in Texas? Do people in Texas want to do things the way they do in California? They probably want to have their own distinct ways of doing things. So under a federal system, the sovereignty of the states to control to some extent how they... how they carry out their affairs, how their states work, is an important thing today in the American governmental system, the federal system. So that matters a lot today, and it mattered a lot to George Mason in his refusal to sign the Constitution without a Bill of Rights. And I would say that probably this whole notion about states' rights within the context of early America has a lot to do with this whole idea of national harmony in the sense that you don't want... Congregationalists from Massachusetts imposing their views on Anglicans down in Virginia, that would create a sort of sense of social disharmony. Yeah, so if we're all going to get along in one country, we're going to have to accommodate each other one way or another somehow. And the way to do that was to have a federal system where the different states had some sovereignty. Had some sovereignty, some control over their affairs, yes. All right, so George Mason, he was from Virginia. a large state university in Fairfax, Virginia, George Mason University is named for him. He's better known in Virginia because he's from Virginia than he is elsewhere in the country. His home, Gunston Hall, is located in Fairfax County, Virginia, outside Washington, D .C. It's only about a 15 -minute drive from where we're recording this, I think. It's preserved. It's open to the public.
18:37 You can go there and learn about him someday if you're ever visiting the area. He was from Virginia, and Virginia's established religion, as we talked about, its established church, was the Church of England. or the Anglican Church, later called the Episcopal Church. So his religious orientation was toward Anglicanism, Episcopalianism, because of that. However, he believed very strongly in the separation of church and state. So he wrote a document called the Fairfax Resolves in 1774, and then he wrote a different document called the Virginia Declaration of Rights, which Virginia adopted on June 12, 1776, which is 23 days before the Declaration of Independence. on July 4th. These documents, and particularly the Virginia Declaration of Rights, laid out many principles familiar to us today. And that's because Thomas Jefferson drew on them heavily, particularly on the Virginia Declaration of Rights, when he wrote the Declaration of Independence.
19:31 Some people will say, oh, you know, Thomas Jefferson cribbed it from George Mason. George Mason deserves the credit. That's not really true. But the point is well taken, though, that Jefferson respected Mason's work and drew heavily on him in writing the Declaration. Jefferson drew on a lot of people for the Declaration. He also drew on works by other people. But sitting on his desk was something by George Mason, and that's been forgotten is my point here. And I don't see that as necessarily a failing that you're going to take the best from the best minds of the time. No, no, no. I'm not saying that. I'm just saying that some people will get critical and say things. things like that. Anyway, so the Declaration, but also the Virginia Declaration of Rights formed the basis for the Bill of Rights that James Madison wrote for the Constitution, which was ratified in 1791. And by the way, the Virginia Declaration of Rights also inspired similar verbiage. in many U .S. state constitutions, U .S. state bills of rights, in the French Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen in 1789, and even in the United Nations Charter, which was adopted in 1945. So George Mason's thinking and his work and writing particularly the Virginia Declaration of Rights, casts a long shadow in terms of the...
20:40 As a political theorist, he's... Charters and constitutions of governments and organizations in the future. Yes, he's a very unappreciated political theorist that has contributed a great deal. So what did he say in this, right? So let's go to the Virginia Declaration of Rights. In the first draft, the first draft of the Virginia Declaration of Rights, Mason wrote, now this is going to be in very florid... 18th century style English. With dependent clauses and everything. Yeah, so we'll parse this, but just listen to what he wrote. He wrote, that as religion, or the duty which we owe to our divine and omnipotent creator, and the matter of discharging it, can be governed only by reason and conviction, not by force or violence, and therefore that all men should enjoy the fullest toleration in the exercise of religion, according to the dictates of conscience, unpunished and unrestrained by the magistrate, unless, under color of religion, any man disturb the peace, the happiness, or safety of society or of individuals, and that it is the mutual duty of all to practice Christian forbearance, love, and charity towards each other.
21:53 So let's parse that a little bit and see what he's saying there. Interestingly, he says religion, but then he says, or the duty we owe to our divine and omnipotent creator. So it kind of sounds like he's reflecting, he's acknowledging religion there, but maybe also giving a nod to deism, right? Which is, is that a religion? The creator, right? He's giving a nod there. And the manner of discharging it, okay, so how you go about doing it, can only be, your rituals, in other words, right? Can only be governed by reason and conviction. Reason and conviction. So you have to believe it, but you come to that belief through reason. He's not making an emotional claim here. You think it through, and then you... You make your decision. You develop your convictions based on your reason, okay? And that it can't be governed by force or violence. So you can't threaten anybody in any way. Violence, physical violence, obviously, but even just force, right?
22:44 Maybe you don't commit an act of violence, but maybe you're arresting people, you're jailing people, right? You're using force. Those cannot govern your religious practice in any way, is what he's saying. Only reason and conviction can govern those. Therefore, you should enjoy the fullest toleration. Every man, he says, nowadays we'd say every person, every man and woman, right? Should enjoy the fullest toleration in the exercise of religion, according to what the dictates of their conscience. And he says that the magistrate, so he's talking about the government, right? And the government cannot punish or restrain you from doing that, with one exception. And he says, if by exercising your religion, your religious practices, you disturb the peace. Shout fire in a crowded theater. You disturb the happiness or safety of society or of individuals. Now, there's that tranquility thing again, right?
23:39 So practice your religion, but don't disturb civil society. Don't oppress anybody else while you're doing it. Don't interfere with their rights. Okay, that's what he's saying. So we can't govern what you do. We should not govern and cannot govern what you do and think religiously. But you cannot use that as an excuse to disturb the peace, and you cannot use that as an excuse to oppress other people. Your rights end where another's begins. Now, he also says at the end here, it is the mutual duty of all to practice Christian forbearance, love, and charity towards each other. So all of us have a duty to follow what he explicitly says is Christian teachings. Maybe he's saying if you're Jewish, if you're Muslim, if you're whatever else you are, and the teachings you're following mirror what Christianity teaches, then you're good, I guess is what he's saying there.
24:29 But he does say that you have a duty to carry out these Christian morals. Yes. Or Christian -informed morals, at least, Christianity -informed morals. That's a duty that you have. I see that as, again, reflecting this idea that... that religion provides, that a lot of them had, that religion provides a moral underpinning for how you behave in a society, and therefore it's critical to have it. So you have a duty to carry that out. That's how I read that. So that's the... That's the clause that he wrote about religion in the Virginia Declaration of Rights in the original draft. Now, so they got together in Virginia and considered the adoption of the Declaration of Rights in 1776. And a debate developed in which James Madison, who at the time was a young hotshot from Orange County, Virginia. Protégé of Jefferson's. He was there. He strongly opposed Mason's use of the word toleration. Yes. So what Mason says is that... All men should enjoy the fullest toleration and the exercise of religion.
25:32 He says, no, no, no. Do not use the word toleration. He said that tolerating a religion was too weak of a construct. And he concluded that, Madison did, that religious toleration, whether granted by the civil state or by a religious authority, was inconsistent with freedom of conscience and was a woefully inadequate objective. Because it doesn't... It's not a guarantee. It's not a guarantee. And toleration means that you're sort of like holding your nose and putting up with something rather than accepting it. I could smack you down for doing it, but I'm going to tolerate you and not do it. Yes. That's not good enough. No, it's not. According to Madison. Madison proposed replacing Mason's Clause, all men should enjoy the fullest toleration and the exercise of religion, with the phrase... All men are equally entitled to the full and free exercise of it, meaning religion, according to the dictates of conscience. So it's not something that's tolerated.
26:33 It's something you're entitled to. What did Mason think about this? There isn't much documentary evidence of what he specifically thought about it. But he appears to have had no real objection to Madison's change. He doesn't appear to have done anything to fight it. Toleration was probably like a term. I would say that when we're looking at some of these writings, we need to take into account that there are certain terms of convenience. And toleration would have been the term of convenience which we might understand as freedom of religion. But Madison does make an important distinction there. I would say that most people would say toleration is a good thing. Sure, fine. But Madison is taking it one step further and saying, well, no, you really want to establish a deeper requirement than just toleration. Mason appears to have had no real problem with that. And so the final version that was adopted is the first legal statement of religious liberty, according to my reading, my research. It's the first legal statement of religious liberty ever really made. What was the year again? 1776. Yeah. And it came out as Article 16 of the Virginia Declaration of Rights.
27:36 And it states. That religion, or the duty which we owe to our Creator and the manner of discharging it, can be directed by reason and conviction, not by force or violence, and therefore all men are equally entitled to the free exercise of religion according to the dictates of conscience, and that it is the mutual duty of all to practice Christian forbearance, love, and charity towards each other. And that's what they agreed to. So, in other words, the free exercise of religion is a right, and all people are entitled to it, Civil authorities must do more than merely tolerate it. They must ensure it. And I think as a statement of original intent, if we're talking about what the original intent is, this is a kind of crucial statement to consider when we're looking at what the original intent is behind the Founding Fathers and the establishment of the United States and the relationship of religion. So that was what they actually officially adopted. But Mason's original draft of what became Article 16 was the one most widely circulated among the other states at the time who were drafting their own constitutions and bills of rights and things.
28:45 So his original draft was probably the one that was most influential on other states, not the modified version that they worked out with Madison. Scholars have noted that Mason wrote and Madison retained the clause that religion or the duty we owe our creator and the manner of discharging it. The retention of this line suggests that both Mason and Madison construed religion as belief in a creator and all of the duties arising from the belief in that creator. So you have to believe in a creator, but then you have to believe the creator assigned duties to you that you must carry out in the honor of that creator. Good works. Good works. This notion is consistent with definitions of religion commonly used at that time, and it included deists, but it excluded atheists. Again, we have that stigma of atheism.
29:31 You cannot, you know, the belief system is that you cannot have a sort of like world without a deity in it. You cannot basically ascribe to a sort of like non -atheistic worldview where everything's just happening because it's happening. A final note on this. A scholar named L. John Van Til observed, that the final version aligned the terms creator, religion, and conscience. So Van Til wrote that religion is the way that a man relates to his creator. But this relationship can be cared for only through conscience. And that conscience employs reason and conviction, not force and violence. So conscience is the only way to discharge the duties of man toward his creator. And therefore, the man must be at liberty to do that. Significantly, the article adds, it is necessary, therefore, to practice Christian forbearance, love, and charity towards each other. So this rests on two assumptions.
30:36 One is that the rights of conscience and vision by the Virginia Convention were to be exercised in a theistic context. And second, that involves not only a relationship between one man and his God, but also the relationship of each man to his neighbor. There we have it again. There is a civic aspect in terms of civic behavior, how one behaves toward one's neighbor. reflected in a religious underpinning, but having a practical, secular, civic effect in terms of how you function in your society. And I see this as a recurring theme put in different ways, maybe coming from different faith traditions, but you keep seeing it over and over again amongst the founders. So that's George Mason. The same power that can establish Christianity in exclusion to all other religions may establish with the same ease a particular sect of Christianity to the exclusion of all other sects. Remonstrance against religious assessments, 1785, James Madison. Now, we've talked about James Madison in his relationship with George Mason. Now it's Madison's time to kind of shine here. So he is known as the father of the Constitution and the Bill of Rights and given his role in the construction and passage
32:07 of both. Madison, along with Hamilton and John Jay, is the author of the Federalist Papers, which explains the original intent in the Constitution, which established and organized the federal government. Now, the Constitution consists of certain points because people don't study the Constitution. It's probably worth saying what it is. You have the organization of the federal government, Articles 1 through 3, the relationship with the states, Article 4, the amendment process, Article 5. establish the Constitution as the supreme law of the land, Article 6, and how the Constitution is to be ratified. This is the Constitution.
32:48 And then what follows, the first 10 amendments, which Madison is also associated with, are called the Bill of Rights. And these were kind of a result of Mason's role in insisting that we have those as part of our Constitution to prevent excesses on the part of the federal government. So Madison was probably the most proud of the Constitution, and rightly so, and the Bill of Rights. Because this is what literally creates the American nation. It's not the flag. It's not anything else. It is the Constitution. Madison was a so -so president during the War of 1812, which we might want to address in a future episode.
33:37 But it's really his skill as a legislator that makes Madison a founding father. Madison is exceptional in many ways. He's, first of all, the shortest president of the United States. He is 5 '4". Jefferson and Washington are both over 6 feet tall, and Adams is 5 '7". So just imagine how tall Madison would have stood. He would have probably needed a box to preside over anything to stand upon. He's a very quiet and scholarly person. He is, interestingly, for someone from Virginia, he did not go to William and Mary, which was the usual location for turning out statesmen, lawyers, ministers, et cetera, during the colonial period. He instead went to Princeton, New Jersey. And this is because of the wising tide of deism that was the result of Scottish members of the Enlightenment coming over to teach at William and Mary. The idea was to send Madison to a more conventionally religious institution like Princeton, as it was at the time. And what was Princeton's denomination? Presbyterian. It was Presbyterian? Okay. Yes. So he's also a protege of Jefferson. who literally sent him truckloads of books from Europe when he was serving as U .S. ambassador, possibly the greatest act of friendship and influence that Jefferson could have over the development of the Constitution
35:09 and the Bill of Rights. Madison used these offerings as a delegate to the Constitution to provide insight into possible structures of the federal government, which, again, was his proudest achievement. Very little is known about the exact religious views of James Madison like other founding fathers. He did not advertise them. It's probably considered impolitic to do so. We see what happens when you're Thomas Paine and you start shouting from the tops of buildings what you believe, what effect that can have on your popularity and influence. He is well -versed, though, in religious matters. He could read the Bible in both Hebrew and Greek and was familiar with a wide variety of authors on religious matters. Interestingly, you know, how we see that with Washington, there's no—he doesn't necessarily indulge in communion. Madison was never confirmed in the Anglican Church despite attempts to kind of maintain a more conventional religious upbringing. He may have held Unitarian views similar to John Adams, some people think.
36:21 He was profoundly affected by the persecution and arrest of dissenters in Culpeper County, an event he witnessed shortly after returning from Princeton. He was still recounting this story in the White House 40 years later. His wife, Dolly Madison, was a former Quaker and had a similar series of tales involving the persecution of Quakers. So religious persecution was very much a part of both members of the family's backstory. They both were concerned about this. They had witnessed it. They had seen extreme violence, and they wished to avoid it. For a lot of the other founding fathers, they don't necessarily have this reference point, which I think is interesting. They have a historical reference point, but they don't have a personal one where they're literally seeing people dragged away to jail for their belief systems. And again, to me, that kind of shows why he was so adamant about the idea of not having toleration in the Virginia Declaration of Rights, because if you're merely tolerating something, then... you can decide not to tolerate it. And when you do, all these terrible things can happen that he saw happen. Hence the quote that we lead off with. So he wanted to not just tolerate, but demand that the state, require the state, I should say, to make sure everybody has religious freedom. Everybody is the same.
37:36 Everybody is the same before the law, which is an important tradition that we see refined in later amendments beyond the the Bill of Rights, but an important component of the Constitution to this very day. We are all equal under the law. Madison drafted the Virginia Plan, which contributed to the language of the first three articles dealing with the organization of the federal government in the Constitution with the three distinct branches and the bicameral legislature. Later, as one of the authors of the Federalist Papers, Madison promoted the ratification of the Constitution with these articles here. Initially, Madison did not think a Bill of Rights was necessary.
38:26 He felt like the Constitution says it all. This is what the Constitution is supposed to do. These are the responsibilities of the federal government. in response to arguments between himself or debates with George Mason, he kind of became converted to the idea of a Bill of Rights over time. This is sort of the dynamics of politics before we have cable news and all sorts of tweeting and such that people could actually have a debate about... issues of the day and actually change their mind and agree to come to a different conclusion based on the strength of their opponent's position there. And this is something we see among members of the founding fathers' generation. It's curious that he and Mason interacted, you know, on the Virginia Declaration of Rights in 1776, but then, you know, 15 years later, roughly. He doesn't see necessarily the need for a Bill of Rights at first. Maybe he felt that the states had enough power of their own. Yeah. That they could provide the protections in the Bill of Rights. And then maybe Mason convinced him that, no, no, you need a federal one as well. Yeah. That's what it sounds like to me, but I'm just making that up as I'm listening to you. I think that what you're saying is actually the case here. Because I think when Madison is looking at the Constitution initially, It is about establishing the federal government.
39:57 And that's why I felt it was useful to go through the initial—when you're looking at this, this is not a document about rights. This is an organizational document, a document about organizational principles. This is how things are meant to function. And it's important to keep that in mind. And that is what Madison saw as the reason we needed to create a federal government system. And we needed to have explained what the various branches did, what their limits on their powers were and things like that. And then the states can then make sure that they ensure everybody's rights with regard to whatever, including religion. Yes.
40:39 But Mason felt that the Constitution as written might allow the federal government to intrude upon the sovereignty of states. And he was against that. So it sounds like that may be where he and he and Madison. came to an agreement that you needed to have a bill of rights well when you talk about the constitution as being the supreme law of the land then that is you know in the federal government being the arbitrator of that that's where i think this comes into play here and i i think this might have been some an element that madison didn't quite reckon with at first but was was able to be persuaded later on as a member of the first session of congress Madison reviewed over 200 submissions and drafted amendments that later became the Bill of Rights. So there were lots of different things that people felt were important to be included in the Constitution. And Madison, reader that he was, basically discovered that we really just needed 10, at least to start off with. Madison was pleased with what later became known as the First Amendment. And this is the one that deals with the non -establishment clause of religion in it. This was not, it is the First Amendment not because of significance or importance or value that people invest in it. It's the First Amendment because that was the first one that got passed. All these amendments went up and went through the usual process of ratification.
42:08 First Amendment was the one that came back first of all. So it's not a priority issue. It's an issue of where things emerged on the docket of various legislatures around the country. Madison was most imbued by the British political tradition and with a very strong attachment to Locke. Not so much Montesquieu's notions of the social contract, although there is some social contract data on Locke. During the 18th century, and I think this is an important distinction, British politics is still focused on whether or not one needed to exclude non -Anglicans from the political process, which I've kind of alluded to earlier in this discussion and in the previous episode.
42:54 The rights of non -Anglicans within the British Commonwealth was something that, as Mike brought out, Founding fathers were trying to avoid any sort of controversy over those. Everybody was supposed to have the same equal rights. There was and there is no Christian religion as such. There are religions that ascribe to Christian principles, but there is no single monolithic Christian religion. And this was something that was recognized by the founding fathers, particularly. James Madison, when the Bill of Rights was being crafted. We're looking at, in the foundation of America, Unitarians, Quakers, and Catholics, and subsequently with the Second Great Awakening, which we'll get into in the next episode, very different religious groups here, and their rights were something that Madison sought to sought to establish as bedrock principles within the Constitution. These are things that establish the principles that today can cause people to question whether or not certain religions are Christian or not, but not question their ability to exist. The beauty of the First Amendment, just to go into some detail about that, because this is part of Madison's legacy, and particularly
44:25 germane to what we're discussing, Is that while people might opine that such things, that there is no test act to ensure that only people of a certain religion, whether it is Christian or not, can participate in the political process. And that was the distinction that was made over in Britain. Because if you have this notion of the world being established by God, that's who is in charge of things. This is a very un -American notion. I think we can say that if you have like a king or someone divinely appointed by God, that this is very much at odds with founding fathers are talking about when they are establishing the Constitution. In this sense, no one is going to be fined for not taking communion four times a year, which was a penalty that was going on in England during the 17th and 18th century, or going to the wrong church. There are no wrong churches under Madison. What Madison was seeking to allow and permit and is part of his legacy.
45:32 is to achieve the right to define one's own religious preference, not through toleration, as Mike said, which implies these beliefs could be odious, but as a fundamental right, which is a somewhat different aspect to how one views these things. The United States were to remain neutral despite all sentiments to the contrary. That was his vision. The government has a duty to ensure that you can practice your religion. it does not merely tolerate the fact that you practice your religion. Yes. That's a key distinction in his mind. And I would say that that's probably not at odds with what other people intended, but I think that it is kind of a new wrinkle on things in terms of how we view this as fundamental. I think that is the key word. I think so. I think that when people like Mason and others use the word tolerate or toleration, they were meaning what Madison was trying to get at. This is the language of the time. Yeah, they were meaning that, but he wanted to put it more forcefully and leave it open to no interpretation whatsoever, and so he recommended that change. And they adopted it. So they must have said, yeah, I see your point. Okay, let's go with that. Yeah, I mean, yeah. This went through the whole process of it. Which brings us to our final founding father,
47:03 I believe we're going to discuss, Alexander Hamilton. He presents a complex picture in many ways. He was born on the island of Nevis, N -E -V -I -S, it's spelled, Nevis. It's in the Caribbean. It's now part of the country of St. Kitts and Nevis. Traditionally, he's viewed as having been raised Presbyterian. That's because his mother was born Christian, and his biological... father, to whom his mother was not married, was Scottish. So the assumption was a Scottish man is going to be Presbyterian. Mother was Christian. He must have been brought up Presbyterian. That was the idea there. There is recent scholarship which has been embraced as being an important contribution to understanding of Hamilton. A book published in 2021 called The Jewish World of Alexander Hamilton by a man named Andrew, and I'm sure I'm going to mess his last name up. But it's Porwancher, P -O -R -W -A -N -C -H -E -R. Porwancher, maybe he pronounces it differently. If he does, I apologize to him. Anyway, this book raises a whole new idea of how Hamilton was raised.
48:10 And it's circumstantial evidence. There's inferences there, but it's well constructed with a lot of evidence. So it's not considered proof. but it's considered to be significant evidence that must be considered that, in fact, Alexander Hamilton was raised Jewish. Could I ask a question here? Sure. When we're saying raised Jewish, does this mean that he is going through the formal rituals of Judaism, such as bar mitzvah and things like that, or is he being raised to Jewish principles? Is that kind of the argument? I don't know, and I'm not sure that the scholarship gets into that, because I'm not sure that they know, okay? Let me show you what they say, and then you can consider what that means. So why does this even come up?
48:56 Well, his mother, Alexander's mother, was married to a man who very well may have been Jewish. He had a last name which was extremely uncommon outside the Jewish community and very common among Jewish men. So it's highly likely that he was Jewish. And there is some evidence that she may have converted to Judaism. Not proven, but there's some evidence of that. Hard to do in any event, though. Well, on Nevis, maybe things were different. I don't know. So her marriage to the Jewish man fell apart. She gave birth to Alexander out of wedlock to the Scottish biological father. Because it's hard to get a divorce over there. Yeah, who was definitely a Christian and probably Presbyterian. But it goes further. So Hamilton, as a youth, received schooling from a Jewish headmistress on Nevis. Now, he never claimed Jewish heritage. As a teenager, he claimed to have been raised in the Church of England.
49:51 That's interesting with a name like Hamilton, which is Scottish. But he also said that he had never taken communion, which was a significant thing for him to say at the time. So, it's a mixed bag of evidence. Yeah. He didn't claim Jewish heritage, but maybe he didn't want to tell people that he had any kind of Jewish heritage. You're asking the question, was he bar mitzvahed? I don't think that they know. Maybe if you delve into it further, you'll find out more information about that. But that didn't come up in my research as being an issue. I didn't even see this. You know, like the book on Hamilton is the Chernow book, which is the basis for the musical, actually. Well, this is a new book. Yeah, this is post. And it's yeah, it's new scholarship. And it's something that's considered worth. really worth considering. It's not considered proof, but really worth considering. He may have actually been raised Jewish to at least some extent. That may have been part of his upbringing. I don't know how significant that is, but it just is. I'm going to make a comment. Hamilton is probably, in the most basic sense of the word, probably the most cosmopolitan of any of the founding fathers. So this is not necessarily at odds with his overall life story, that he would have some influence from Judaism, particularly growing up in the Caribbean there, as opposed to one of the major colonies here. Hamilton also kind of tries to reinvent himself, I will argue, as almost more Catholic than the Pope, more waspy
51:24 than than anybody else once he gets to america takes up his scholarship at king's college and becomes an aide to washington during the revolutionary war he he basically goes goes hogwild into kind of being more part of the establishment than he was actually born into so i'm going to cover some of that Oh, sorry. I didn't mean to... I didn't mean to... That completes my talk on Alexander Allen. I'm sorry. I thought that was coming, yeah. No, no, we're going to talk about some of this, okay? Not some of the details you're providing, but we're going to talk about it. Okay. That's fine. So, whether he was raised Jewish or to what extent he was raised Jewish or not, okay, regardless, he appears to have become an ardent Christian. He certainly was an ardent Christian in his late teens. A destructive hurricane hit Nevis when he was 17 years old.
52:20 And in the aftermath of that hurricane, he wrote a sermon about it. In that sermon, he exhorted the privileged people of the island to be humble before the scythe of God and to use their superfluity, by which I believe he's referring to their money, all the extra money they have that they don't need, according to him, to help the less fortunate. Interesting position for Hamilton to take. Yeah. So at age 17, he comes across as an ardent Christian. And in fact, this sermon brought him to the attention of a Presbyterian minister who sponsored his move to America. Now, you were talking about, you know, that the cosmopolitan nature of his upbringing, right? So we have some kind of Jewish aspect probably going on in his childhood. Or influence. Influence, at least, right? We have his... profession of being Church of England all along, but never taking communion. We have a Presbyterian minister bringing him to North America. So there's a bunch of different religious things going on in his background, and it's maybe a little bit chaotic, and it's not all that well documented, so it's a little bit hard to tell exactly how it all fits together. Well, when you're illegitimate, you lead a chaotic life, and Hamilton was always, I would argue, in search of a father figure, which starts out maybe with this Presbyterian guy who's sponsoring to go to university in New York City, but it later becomes Washington, for sure. How old was he
53:52 when he came to the mainland? Exact age, I'm not sure, but it was based on this sermon when he was 17, so he must have been 17 or 18. Yeah, so it was like a teenager. Late teens, for sure. It's not unusual for someone to be... very young to go to university at that time. Right. You're talking about his upbringing. He did have a pretty chaotic upbringing. You know, his father, biological father, vanished after he and his mother broke up. His mother died. A cousin took him on as being like his guardian, but then the cousin committed suicide. He had an aunt, an uncle, grandmother. They all died. There were bankruptcies. There were... scandals, because he was born out of wedlock, and also because of that there was disinheritance. I mean, all sorts of things he was dealing with as a... And this is all before 20. Yeah, as a child. Yes. You know, and people who experience those kind of things in life, not all of them, but there are a lot of people who then turn to religion for comfort, consolation, inspiration, and all that, right? Maybe he was one of those people. I don't know. I'm just throwing that out there as a possibility based on the childhood he experienced. Because by age 17, when the hurricane came through, he... Came across as an ardent Christian. He impressed people as one. And he's also looking for stability in life, I would argue, as well. Back to this issue of his association with Judaism, by the way. There is a little bit more on that that comes out in the recent scholarship. It was noted in that scholarship, but then also earlier, that he showed an affinity for the Jewish community in the colonies, and later the United States, to an extent beyond
55:24 that of any of the other founding fathers. The other founding fathers' views of Judaism ranged anywhere from toleration to out -and -out anti -Semitism. But Hamilton had connections with various American Jewish communities. Even though the people of that time did not know anything about this possible Jewish upbringing that's been discovered recently, his financial policies in the early United States, when he was Secretary of the Treasury from 1789 to 1795, he favored a national bank and a national assumption of debt. And those are things that just fit into anti -Semitic tropes. Yes. And so there was a tremendous amount of anti -Semitic opprobrium towards him personally, which is kind of ironic.
56:04 And when you think about it, he may have been very closely associated with Jewish people, if not kind of Jewish himself and his upbringing. And to hear this must have had an effect on him as well. Well, if he's down in the Caribbean, this is a highly commercial culture. And so he is actually going to be very much associated with the commercial interest, just where he's born. And based on what we have discussed when we talked about the various Jewish communities in Boston, New York, and Newport, the basic profession of these people in these communities was commercial and mercantile. Hamilton probably would have had closer contact with that community than any of the other founding fathers, just given his background and subsequent associations. So it's been pointed out that regardless of whether he had any Jewish aspect to his upbringing, it could be that the experience that he had as Secretary of the Treasury with all the anti -Semitic stuff that he heard, you know, leveled at people during his tenure. about finance and such, may have made him better understand the plight of the Jewish community and the kind of anti -Semitic tropes that they always put up with all the time.
57:25 So in defending a Jewish client once as a lawyer in New York, he got up and said, has he forgotten? I guess he's talking about the guy that's, you know, the prosecutor or whatever it is, or the opponent, the opponent anyway. Has he forgotten? What this race once were when under the immediate government of God himself, they were selected as the witnesses of his miracles and charged with the spirit of his prophecy. So that's very much Old Testament biblical. That does sound a little bit at odds with what some of the other founding fathers believed, particularly with the discussion of miracles and things like that, though. Sure. Well, yeah. He also went on to say, be the injured party, Jew or Gentile or Christian or pagan. Foreign or native, she, Lady Liberty, she, clothes him with her mantle in whose presence all differences of faiths or births of passions or prejudices, all are called to acknowledge and revere her supremacy. So there he's making an argument about how people of different religious faiths should get the same protection of the law. Consistent with what we've seen elsewhere.
58:34 Which is a close cousin of the idea of freedom of religion in the first place, isn't it? So he expressed those beliefs. Now, what also happened, though, is in the middle of his life, now he only lived to be about 49 years old. So the middle of his life isn't middle age. The middle of his life is maybe his 30s or so, right? In the middle of his life, he seems to have kind of fallen off the wagon when it comes to religion. There's signs that he became quite cynical. He had distanced himself from religious belief. When the Constitution was written, someone asked him, why no God in the Constitution? And he just kind of flippantly said, we forgot. He had an affair with a married woman, which was America's first major sex scandal. Oh, yes. And it horrified religious people that he had done this. And at the time, he did not regularly attend church. So all of these things suggest that in the middle of his life. He distanced himself from religion. He wasn't following the beliefs or the practices really in any way and was giving in to, you know, animal passions and things like that. He could get frustrated very easily, you know, and he would seek redress in various ways. This affair was not inconsistent with his earlier behavior because Martha Washington famously named her Tomcat Hamilton because he was always at the... female feline cats and making his way around there. And so this was something that was readily understood by people, but it wasn't made public like the scandal involving his mistress there. So that was his second phase,
1:00:07 his more or less non -religious phase, apparently, of his life. But then later in his life, religion began to preoccupy him. He became quite religious again. Is this when he's Secretary of the Treasury or after? I don't have an exact time link between those two. Probably around that time, though, because he was horrified by the excesses of the French Revolution. And the French Revolution kicked off in 1789 and went on for a good 10 years, depending how you want to count. He was horrified by that. And that's right about the same time as the drafting of the Constitution and all that is when the French Revolution happened, right? 1789. So he was horrified by that, by the French Revolution. He viewed it. what they had done as terrible in terms of their excesses.
1:00:50 And then they're also trying to come in and undermine the federal government with their own agents to make for a more pro -French foreign policy. Who are they? The French. The French Revolutionary Government had their own agent. In the United States. In the United States, Citizen Jeunet, he was known. And Citizen Jeunet was here to influence policy, which Hamilton was more pro -British because of the whole commercial orientation, our leading trading partner had been Britain. And that's where he saw where the United States should emphasize this foreign policy because it was about... commercial interest in making for a sound economic system. Well, that being said about the commercial aspects of what he thought, it's also that he was horrified by the excesses of the French Revolution and he wrote several essays critical of the efforts of the French to overthrow the Christian religion. Because he said that to do so would rob, quote, mankind of its best consolations and most animating hopes and make a gloomy desert of the universe. He noted the praise of a civilized world is justly due to Christianity. So by around this time, he'd gone back again to being very, very pro -religion and very pro -Christian. He said that Christianity, later in his life, he said Christianity formed the basis of all law and morality and,
1:02:21 quote, the world would be a hellish place without it, as one observer noted. But he's not focusing on miracles. He's not focusing on life everlasting. He's focusing on order and more public morality, though, when he makes these statements. Yes, although he also mentions mankind's best consolations and most animating hopes. Okay. So that's life everlasting. And without those, it would be a gloomy desert of the universe without him. So, I mean, yeah, there's more to it than that in his thinking. As Inspector General of the new United States Army in the Revolutionary War, we had the Continental Army in the Revolutionary War. That was done away with, but then we created the United States Army, which we have today.
1:03:03 He asked that Congress fund a chaplain for every brigade in the Army. In 1802, he and his wife, Eliza, purchased a country home, which they called the Grange. Which is now in Manhattan proper, just given the growth of the city. Yeah. Being at the Grange allowed Hamilton to spend more time with his children. And on Sunday mornings, they gathered in the garden to sing hymns. And Hamilton read the Bible aloud to his family. And he also spoke to his wife about his desire to build a chapel on the property. So he was getting very much into religion in the last years of his life. He was the driving force behind an effort to form something called the Christian Constitutional Society. He proposed it in 1802, along with a fellow named James Baird. And the Christian Constitutional Society was supposed to bolster the Federalist Party, that was his political party, against Thomas Jefferson by uniting Christian faith with political activism.
1:03:57 Its goals were to support the Christian religion and the U .S. Constitution. He intended it to organize voters, support worthy candidates, and spread political information, and this reflected a late -life focus he had on connecting public faith to political action. In an 1802 letter to the co -founder of the society, James Baird, he said that the society's object is, first, the support of the Christian religion, second, the support of the United States. I have carefully examined the evidence of the Christian religion, he told a friend. And if I was sitting as a juror upon its authenticity, I would unhesitatingly give my verdict in its favor. And to his wife, he said, I have studied it and I can prove its truth as clearly as any proposition ever submitted to the mind of man. There was a big issue when he was on his deathbed. Now, he went and fought a duel with Aaron Burr. Aaron Burr. Who was vice president at the time. Supposedly, he alleged the sort of thing that... got Hamilton to this point. He made a comment, this is a theory, it's not a fact, because the real reason is not known, but he made a comment about Hamilton having, about Burr having incest with his daughter, Theodosia, and this so outraged Burr. that that's what led to the challenge. So it was a matter of honor.
1:05:17 Yes. Well, anyway, he went and fought a duel with Burr. He lost. He was shot. He was taken to his deathbed. He lived 31 hours after he was shot before he died in 1804. And there was a big dramatic thing there on his deathbed where he was desperate to receive communion before he died. He asked the rector of Trinity Church, the Episcopal Bishop of New York, president of Columbia College, was the first guy he asked. He said, would you give me communion? the Reverend Benjamin Moore, and Moore said no, because the practice of dueling was horribly immoral and wrong, and he had been morally wounded in a duel, and also because he'd not been a regular churchgoer.
1:05:57 So no. So Hamilton turned to a friend of his who was the Reverend John M. Mason, who was the pastor of Scotch Presbyterian Church. Mason also said no. He said his church had a principle of never offering the Lord's Supper privately to any person. under any circumstances. But then finally Mason relented, came back and said, okay, I'll give you communion and gave him communion. And that was very comforting to Hamilton. He said, I'm a sinner. I have a tender reliance on the mercy of the almighty through the merits of the Lord Jesus Christ. And that convinced, I guess that convinced Moore to have a change of heart and minister communion. After his passing, Eliza noticed, discovered a hymn. and a letter that Hamilton wrote for her on the morning before the duel. And at the end, he instructed, fly to the bosom of your God and be comforted with my last idea. I shall cherish the sweet hope of meeting you in a better world. Adieu, best of wives and best of women. Embrace all my darling children for me, ever yours, A .H. So he went through three phases in his childhood. He had a difficult childhood. There may or may not have been Jewish influence on him to some extent.
1:07:03 There probably was some. He became an ardent Christian. Then he kind of stopped practicing religion for a while. Then later in life, and maybe it was the excesses of the French Revolution that prompted this in him. I don't know that for sure, but it was around that time, apparently. He then became more preoccupied with religion to the point where it pretty much was a driving force in his life in his last years. And that's Alexander Hamilton. I can believe that. I'm just going to make—I have read the Chernow book, which, again, is supposed to be like the definitive book on Hamilton. and I've read other books on Hamilton. I think Hamilton had this amazing period in his life, which I would say is roughly the Constitutional Convention all the way up to when he resigns as Secretary of the Treasury for the, I think her name was Mariah Roberts. That was the woman he was having the affair with, and she was actually kind of using him for her own, financial purposes with her husband. She was having this affair with Hamilton along with the husband's permission and agreement because of the inside information she could gain from Hamilton that benefited them. I think Hamilton out of power without really a future to work towards made him absolutely dangerous. into the point that he really wanted to have a war with France, which we were not really prepared for. And I
1:08:33 think this might have also accounted for some of his greater religiosity as he found himself. Because he was kind of isolated. He was used to a larger area to operate in as treasurer of the federal government. He was a great treasurer, and the things that he proposed and did were great. But once he's out of office, he becomes kind of, a nuisance. He was definitely a nuisance to John Adams. He was constantly writing him about designs for buttons. You're engaging the president of the United States who was trying to avoid a war with France, which Hamilton is pushing for. Hamilton is a member of Adams' party, and he's sending him designs for buttons, and he wants Adams to write him a note commenting on it. And then when Adams is not really... responding as he would like, he kind of tries to bring Washington back on the political scene to be like the general who is going to fight this war with the French, which ensures that Hamilton is going to get preferential treatment because Hamilton is kind of like one of the sons that Washington never had. And he could be quite resentful to Washington at times, but it's just... I feel Hamilton just kind of like came undone. And that might reflect why he adopted some of these contrary religious views later on in life. You mentioned Chernow and the quote about Hamilton thought that the world would
1:10:08 be a hellish place without it. Christianity, that's from Chernow's book. And Chernow also notes, it is striking how religion preoccupied Hamilton during his final years. Okay, so we've covered 10 of the founding fathers in great detail. Are there any common themes and ideas that continue to appear? To me, what I see over and over again in various ways is that these men came from different faith traditions, right? Different denominations.
1:10:59 But all Christian. Different sets of belief. All Christian? Yeah. They seem to share an idea that civil tranquility was very important to them. And again, this makes sense because of the religious wars of the 17th century. Even if you look at the history that's going on in Britain at the beginning of the 18th century, it is about how these religious differences are kind of undermining the ability of the state to function. Yes. They were very concerned that you have a society which is tranquil. They didn't want to have civil strife. And order. Well, to have tranquility, you have to have order. If you don't have order, it won't be very tranquil.
1:11:46 So yes, and civil order, correct. And at least initially, at least initially for most of them, there is this desire to avoid party. friction, the kind of distinctions with party. And parties were based around religion over in England. The Tories were all like high Anglicans. Sure, sure. But fundamentally, you're coming down to a religious issue there, right? Yes. And in terms of religion, they didn't want religion to be a source of strife. Therefore, they thought that the only way to avoid religion becoming a source of strife within society is to not try to limit or control it. Because whenever a a particular denomination is favored by the government, it's going to cause friction. It's going to end in strife. So you must tolerate or go beyond toleration. You must require that the government be neutral toward all religions. At the same time, I think another component of the tranquility is that religion is important to them. Yes. They believe that religion provides you with a moral framework.
1:12:54 in which to live your life, which, because it shows you how to treat your neighbor, how to interact with your neighbor, how to treat your neighbor, that will result also in tranquility because you and your neighbor won't be fighting. So you won't have factions fighting within a government. You also won't have individuals fighting with one another if you have a religious framework for it. But if you insist on only one religious framework, then you will have strife. Yes. I see that as a common theme amongst these men. I would agree. I mean, religion as a source of public morality, religion as a source of political tranquility. When you are creating a new nation out of 13 colonies, you want to minimize the differences rather than to accentuate them. Now, Blake, I know that you've mentioned more than once about, yes, but these all were Christians.
1:13:44 They were all Christians of one stripe or another. Yes, I want you to kind of extemporize on what that means to you. But did they? regard each other as Christians? Were they of the sort to believe that, say, Adams was a Christian or... Well, let's take those as two separate issues. First off, let's start just with Christianity generally. What do you think? Well, again, this was a time in which it was not acceptable to be an atheist. Yeah. And some of these people probably, I mean, I think the deists probably toyed with the idea in their minds, but would never... come out with that publicly because it was unacceptable well it also they also you know even somebody who was as as uh like voltaire voltaire who was an influence uh voltaire is having a dinner party at his home in switzerland and one of the guests is basically arguing that there is no hell And Voltaire immediately shushes him up because he's talking about this in front of the servants. And so when the servants leave, he says, do you want us to be killed in our beds?
1:14:51 If we do not have the belief in hell to kind of motivate people to good behavior, then there will be no limits on any sort of excesses imaginable. This is not inconsistent with, say, what Burke is arguing in the reflections on the revolution in France there, which inspires Paine, Paine's Age of Reason here. So the idea that you, have a life without religion or a life without the components of religion is likely to lead to civil strife or people just basically going crazy. Yeah, I mean, and I think that fits with this, again, like we said, the idea that - It may plug back into this morality. Religion is a fundamental basis of morality that a lot of them seem to - Even with the most extreme elements of the Enlightenment, like Voltaire, who was also dismissed as being an atheist, he was a deist. It appears to be, you know, unacceptable to be an atheist.
1:15:47 It also appears to be pretty unacceptable to be a Unitarian. That's what I'm kind of finding out as well from this. Not yet. Well, I mean, you know, you were saying that Adams got in a lot of trouble for being Unitarian. John Quincy Adams did. John Adams did not. He had to tread carefully, though, about it, didn't he? No, no. He was overtly a Unitarian and no one said anything about it. I looked because I was curious about this very point. And I looked at the books that I have on the election of 1796 and the election of 1800. He does not get any criticism for religious belief at all. But there is a longstanding thing dating back in the colonial times about exclusion of Unitarians, how you had to be a Trinitarian Christian. He did talk about that as well. So there was a stigma against being a Unitarian.
1:16:36 And the various, you know, faith traditions that were founding the colonies. It didn't really become an issue until 1824 with John Quincy Adams, though. It was an issue in that time because it was considered to be. So the Unitarian problem comes up after the Great Second Great Awakening. All right. So for these guys, this wasn't an issue yet. This wasn't an issue. All right. Now I understand that better. OK, so fine. So you could be a Unitarian in this period and people would just take it. fine one of the one of the religious yeah okay that makes a lot more sense because then i was asking the wrong thing earlier in the discussion i was saying how could you be deist and then not be in favor of unitarianism as well or accepting unitarianism but i'm confusing i guess i was confusing the the the you know the 18th century with the second great awakening then yes in fact you could be a deist and be unitarian or trinitarian nobody really cared I had that all wrong in that part of the discussion then. It's not until the Second Great Awakening comes along that we have that distinction. Yes.
1:17:33 All right. And I think this is an important distinction. I didn't realize that either. Okay, very well. Now I get it. I think this is an important distinction to see just how things change. Because when we start getting into the period of American history. After the 1820s, the so -called Age of Jackson, the period in which the Second Great Awakening is kind of in full throttle, life becomes very much more patriarchal and conservative in how people view society in general than they did during the... founding fathers in the Enlightenment, and some of this has to do with the French Revolution and people's reaction to that. So we'll get into that next time. Yes. But in terms of the founding fathers then, okay, so... They're all of Christian background, Judeo -Christian values. They grew up in some kind of a church. And it influenced them. And it influenced them. And they continued, whether they fully believed it or not, they continued to go to church and engage in the ritual. Unless you're getting into pain and he's the extreme.
1:18:45 Correct. It's sort of like Hamilton is one extreme, Hamilton, late Hamilton is one extreme, and pain is the other extreme. You know, when we think about the founding of the colonies, right, and we talk, the various colonies, and we talk about... Roger Williams in Rhode Island. You know, he may have reflected best what the founders intended, really, when he founded Rhode Island. Right. You know, because he himself was a Puritan. He was a devout Puritan. He just felt that you shouldn't order everybody else around the way Puritans tended to do and tell them what to believe because he thought that corrupted religion. He thought you needed to be religiously tolerant. It was fine to engage other people about their religious beliefs, but not dictate them to them and that kind of thing. That's really, to me, a precursor of the way this kind of worked out with the founders, you know, 100 and something years later. Well, as what became the United States became more religiously diverse, because you have the founding of the colonies, and then by the time you get to the revolution, you don't really have single faith elements in any of the colonies. No, they all evolved, even Maryland. which was started by Catholics became... Catholics become minorities.
1:19:55 They become a minority. We discussed that last time, but I'm just trying to say now when we look at the founders themselves, which is our topic this time, the act that the people involved in it, we're also seeing how they were expressing a lot of ideas that I thought that Roger Williams was a precursor of that in the way he was looking at the foundation of Rhode Island in many ways. So, I mean, I think that they understood that... Like, you know, Marshall, you've said there isn't just one Christianity, right? There's all sorts of different beliefs that fall under the umbrella of Christianity. They seem to understand that. They seem to understand that, you know, friction between the different denominations causes strife. They didn't want that. That was the big issue to them to me. We don't want religious strife.
1:20:36 Yeah. Therefore, because of that, you have to have freedom of conscience, freedom of religion. Yeah. Now, a lot of them were deists. Which we can sort of understand, I think, but the whole deism, it removed the emotion from the religion, which is what led to the first great awakening. Christian rationalism, it's been called. Yes. In George Washington's case, for example, but others too, Christian rationalism. And Jefferson, I think, expressed this with the Jefferson Bible, cutting all the miracles. Precisely. So there's value in religion, but only through a rational view of it. not through superstitious views of it, not through emotional views of it. That was their approach to religion. And they went about it in different ways, but a lot of them seem, not all of them, but a lot of them seem to have worked their way through life developing these thoughts and then putting them into practice in terms of what they did in the First Amendment and precursors to that First Amendment. So did they found a Christian nation? What did they found? What were they trying to found? That's our question here before us. They founded a distinctly secular nation. Government. A distinctly secular government, I should have said. Informed by Christian morality. Informed by Christianity. But not dictating Christian belief. Yes. So despite their differing religious views and faith traditions, the Founding
1:22:06 Fathers took an approach to religion in the new United States. that emphasized civic tranquility, based on a right to worship as one pleased, and on the moral guidance that religious teachings gave regarding how people should treat their neighbors. Influenced by the Age of Enlightenment, the founders emphasized reason in the practice of religion, and in the role of religion in civic affairs. But near the end of the 18th century, a new religious movement, the Second Great Awakening, would begin to sweep through the early republic. It would place an emphasis on a personal God and an emotional Christianity. We'll discuss the awakening in our next episode. That's it for this episode of the United States of Amnesia.
1:22:56 Thank you for listening. We hope you learned something, and we hope you discovered new ways of looking at things you had already heard or thought about, or perhaps hadn't heard about. If you enjoyed it, that's great. If we made you mad, that's okay too. Either way, email us at usa .amnesia at gmail .com and let us know what you think. Also, let us know about anything you think we missed or got wrong. We'd like to know about that too. And of course, please like and subscribe and let your friends and neighbors know about us. We also have a website. It's www .usofamnesia .com. For Marshall, Mike, and myself, Blake Henke. Till next time.
Spotify
Amazon Music
Apple Podcasts
YouTube